Short-Term vs. Long-Term Rentals: Which Strategy Is Best for You?

If you’ve been thinking about diving into the world of real estate investment, you’ve likely found yourself at a crossroads. Should you go the traditional route with long-term rentals or embrace the ever-growing world of short-term rentals like Airbnb? As an Airbnb Superhost who’s been on both sides, I’m here to help you break it down and figure out which strategy is the right fit for your lifestyle, goals, and financial aspirations.

In this article, we’ll look at the pros and cons of both short-term rentals vs. long-term rentals, weigh out the risks, and ultimately help you decide which is best for you. We’ll also dig into how renting out Airbnb can be a game-changer and how Airbnb can make money for you faster than you might think. Ready? Let’s dive in!

‍

‍

Short-Term Rentals: Show Me the Money

‍

Let’s get straight to the point and discuss the elephant in the room that you are probably wondering right now: Should you consider renting out Airbnb or any other short-term rental platform? I mean the appeal of short-term rentals is clear. Whether you’re renting out a single room or an entire home, you can host a revolving door of guests from around the world while charging nightly (or weekly) rates instead of locking in a fixed monthly rate. But is it all sunshine and roses? Let's break it down.

‍

Pros of Short-Term Rentals

• Higher Earning Potential Arguably the biggest selling point of short-term rentals is the potential for higher earnings. Unlike long-term rentals where you’re typically tied to a fixed monthly rent, with short-term rentals, you can adjust your prices based on demand, seasons, and local events. Hosting through Airbnb makes money by leveraging these higher rates during peak travel times. For example, if there’s a local festival or holiday weekend, you can raise your nightly rates and bring in significantly more than you would from a long-term tenant. Let’s say you rent your home for $200 per night. Even if you only get guests for half the month, that’s still $3,000—more than you’d likely make from a long-term rental for the whole month.‍
• Flexibility Want to take a vacation or use the property for your personal staycations? With short-term rentals, you can block off dates when the space is unavailable. This flexibility is one of my favorite parts of hosting. By renting out Airbnb, you’re not tied to a year-long lease with tenants; instead, you can come and go as you please, using the property whenever you need it.‍
• Lower Commitment Short-term rentals allow for short-term commitments. If things aren’t working out or if you want to pause hosting, it’s much easier to do so with Airbnb. There’s no long-term lease you need to honor, and you can adjust your availability anytime. Plus, if your local market suddenly shifts or you’re in a slow season, you’re not locked into a low rate for the entire year.‍
• Less Wear and Tear: Preserve Your Property Worried about the impact on your home? Surprisingly, short-term rentals can result in less wear and tear compared to long-term tenants. Since the property isn't occupied 100% of the time, there's downtime when your place is empty, allowing you to perform maintenance and keep everything in tip-top shape. Plus, guests tend to spend most of their time exploring rather than staying indoors, especially if you're in a tourist-friendly location. Regular cleaning between stays also means issues are spotted and addressed promptly, preventing small problems from becoming big headaches.

Cons of Short-Term Rentals

• Inconsistent Income While the potential for high earnings is real, so is the possibility of vacancies. Unlike long-term rentals, short-term rentals are not guaranteed to be occupied all the time. There will be off-seasons or slower periods where bookings drop off, and income becomes inconsistent. As someone who’s been hosting for years, I’ve learned to budget for these slower months by keeping an eye on local events and adjusting my rates to remain competitive.‍
• More Hands-On Let’s be honest—renting out Airbnb can be a bit more work than long-term rentals. You’ll need to manage bookings, manage cleanings between guests, communicate with guests regularly, and handle any issues that arise. This can be time-consuming, especially if you’re managing the property on your own. I’ve found that automating as much as possible—using smart locks, self-check-in, and employing a reliable cleaning team—helps reduce the workload.‍
• Higher Operating Costs One area where I see new hosts underestimate is the higher operating costs of short term rentals. Think about it, if you are doing it right, you're offering a full service vacation experience that includes fully furnishing and stocking the property with not only the essentials like linens, kitchen essentials, and toilet paper, but also extra amenities like coffee and toiletries. Not to mention monthly utility costs (electricity, water, Wi-Fi, and cable), and extra insurance costs needed to cover your investment, and the operating costs quickly add up and dwarf long-term rental operating costs in comparison. However, I've learned to factor these costs into my nightly rates and occupancy goals to make sure costs are covered and maximize your profit margins.

‍

‍

Long-Term Rentals: Stability, Less Work, But Less Control

‍

On the flip side, long-term rentals can offer a much more laid-back, consistent way to invest in real estate. With long-term rentals, you’re signing a lease for a set period, usually a year, and receiving fixed monthly payments. Let's consider the pros and cons of long-term rentals.

‍

Pros of Long-Term Rentals

• Consistent Monthly Income Perhaps the biggest advantage of long-term rentals is the stability of income. Once you sign a lease with a tenant, you’ll receive a steady payment every month. There’s no need to worry about vacancies during the off-season or fluctuating prices based on demand. This is perfect for people who prefer reliable, predictable cash flow. Knowing you’ll have a specific amount coming in each month provides peace of mind, especially if you’re using rental income to pay the mortgage or fund other expenses.‍
• Less Management Long-term rentals tend to require much less hands-on work. You’re not managing multiple guest turnovers, cleaning schedules, or constant communication. Tenants move in, settle down, and (hopefully) take care of the property for the duration of their lease. This low-maintenance setup can free up your time, especially if you have a full-time job or other commitments.‍
• Fewer Property Expenses Long-term tenants are often responsible for their own utilities and basic property maintenance, such as lawn care or minor repairs. This reduces your overall expenses and responsibilities as the landlord, especially compared to short-term rentals where you’re responsible for cleaning, utilities, and guest supplies like toiletries.

Cons of Long-Term Rentals

• Lower Earning Potential While long-term rentals provide consistency, they often don’t offer the same high earning potential as short-term rentals. You’re tied to a fixed rate for the length of the lease, which means no opportunity to capitalize on high-demand seasons or local events. This lack of flexibility in pricing means you might be leaving money on the table. In markets with high tourist activity, short-term rentals can easily out-earn long-term leases, especially when demand is high. If you’re in a prime location, renting out Airbnb could potentially generate more income than a year-long tenant.
• ‍Less Flexibility Once a lease is signed, you’re locked in for the duration of the agreement. If you decide you want to sell the property, use it yourself, or raise the rent, you’ll have to wait until the lease is up. With long-term tenants, you also lose the flexibility to use the property for personal vacations or family stays, something that short-term rentals allow with ease.‍
• Longer Tenant Commitments While consistent rent checks are nice, you’re also committing to a tenant for the long haul. If you end up with a tenant who’s difficult to deal with or fails to pay rent, it’s much harder (and more expensive) to remove them. Bad tenants can cause long-term headaches that are difficult to fix without legal action.

‍

‍

Let's Talk Dollars and Cents

‍

So, which makes more financial sense for you: short-term rentals or long-term rentals? While short-term rentals have the clear earning potential advantage, the answer also largely depends on your goals, location, and willingness to be involved in the day-to-day operations.

‍

Short-Term Rentals: Watch Your Airbnb Make Money Quickly

‍

As we already discussed, short-term rentals obviously have a higher earning potential, especially if you’re in a tourist-heavy location or near major attractions. The ability to adjust pricing, the opportunity to serve a higher number of paying guests in a short period of time which creates the potential to see your Airbnb make money quickly are huge advantages. However, this comes with more hands-on management and a higher risk of vacancy during slow seasons.

For those who have a slightly higher risk tolerance, enjoy meeting and hosting new people, appreciate flexibility, and have the time to manage a more active investment, renting out Airbnb could be the perfect fit. With the right property and pricing strategy, the returns can be far greater than traditional rentals.

‍

Long-Term Rentals: Slow and Steady Wins the Race

‍

Long-term rentals, on the other hand, offer the comfort of stability. If you prefer a more hands-off investment with guaranteed monthly income, this might be the right route for you. However, it’s important to note that long-term rentals generally offer lower earning potential and less flexibility in terms of using the property or adjusting rent based on market trends. Long-term rentals are best for investors who are risk-averse, looking for consistent, passive income without the need to constantly manage the property.

‍

‍

Which Investment Strategy is Right for You?

‍

Ultimately, the decision between renting out Airbnb style or sticking with long-term rentals may simply come down to your personal preferences, financial goals, and how involved you want to be in the process. As an Airbnb Superhost, I can attest that short-term rentals can be both lucrative and fulfilling. But they're not without challenges. Weigh the pros and cons carefully, maybe even dip your toes in both waters to see what suits you best. Remember, real estate investment isn't a one-size-fits-all game.

‍

So, which side are you leaning towards? Short-term or long-term? Whatever path you choose, equip yourself with knowledge, stay adaptable, and keep your eyes on your goals.  Afterall, any real estate investment can be a powerful way to build wealth and achieve financial freedom. Happy hosting (or leasing)!

‍